Kea vs. dhcpd, bigger picture

  1. dhcpd (ISC DHCP) and OMAPI:
  • dhcpd (Internet Systems Consortium DHCP) is a widely-used DHCP server implementation.
  • OMAPI (Object Management Application Programming Interface) is a mechanism provided by dhcpd to manage and control DHCP server configuration and lease information programmatically.
  • OMAPI allows external applications to connect to the dhcpd server, make configuration changes, and retrieve lease information using a C API.
  1. Kea and REST API:
  • Kea is an open-source DHCP server developed by the Internet Systems Consortium (ISC) as an alternative to dhcpd.
  • Kea provides a modern REST API (Representational State Transfer) for managing DHCP server configuration and lease information.
  • The Kea REST API allows external applications to interact with the Kea server through standard HTTP methods (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE) using JSON or XML payloads.

Comparison of OMAPI and Kea REST API:

  1. Functionality:
  • OMAPI provides a C API for programmatic management of dhcpd, including configuration changes and lease retrieval.
  • Kea REST API offers similar functionality but exposes it through a modern, web-based API using standard HTTP methods.
  1. Ease of Use and Integration:
  • OMAPI requires programming knowledge and the use of C API calls to interact with dhcpd. It may have a steeper learning curve for developers.
  • Kea REST API utilizes a familiar and widely adopted web-based API approach, making it more accessible to developers and easier to integrate with other systems.
  1. Flexibility and Extensibility:
  • OMAPI’s capabilities are limited to what is provided by dhcpd and its C API. Extending functionality may require modifications to the dhcpd source code.
  • Kea REST API is designed to be highly extensible and customizable. It provides hooks and plugins that allow for additional functionality and integration with external systems.
  1. Security and Authentication:
  • OMAPI lacks built-in security mechanisms and requires external measures, such as IP-based restrictions or VPNs, to secure communication with dhcpd.
  • Kea REST API supports secure communication over HTTPS and provides authentication mechanisms like API keys, OAuth, or integration with existing identity providers.
  1. Modernization and Future Development:
  • dhcpd and OMAPI have been widely used for many years and have a mature codebase. However, development and new feature additions may be slower compared to Kea.
  • Kea is actively maintained and developed by ISC, ensuring continuous improvement, bug fixes, and feature enhancements based on evolving DHCP requirements.
1 Like